Logo

The year of workplace law upheaval

Parliament, the FWO, unions, employees and employers alike grappled with the ever-complex Fair Work Act in 2023. 

.

The Fair Work Ombudsman has had a very busy year. Its 2023 annual report detailed $509 million in unpaid wages recovered for 251,475 workers in FY 2022-23, the second-highest result after $532 million was clawed back only a year prior.

The workplace watchdog and chief enforcer of the Fair Work Act also said it entered into 15 enforceable undertakings, filed 81 lawsuits and issued 2,424 compliance notices.

 

FWO boss Anna Booth called for businesses, especially big corporates and universities, to do better, with names like Suncorp, David Jones, Politix, Crown, UTS, Starbucks, Best & Less and St Vincent’s all guilty of underpaying workers. 

 

“All employers must place a higher priority on ensuring they are meeting all their workers’ lawful entitlements, including by improving their payroll and governance and investing in advice,” Ms Booth said. 

 

However, Rebecca Thistleton, director of thinktank McKell Institute, said that for every one of the FWO’s successes, “we know there are far more instances that are never investigated and workers who are never properly compensated”. 

The FWO only recovered about two-thirds of an estimated $850 million in yearly unpaid wages and businesses habitually exploited its limited resources, the McKell Institute said.

CEO Ed Cavanough said actual wage theft could be as high as $1.35 billion since data failed to capture the incorrect payment of penalty or award rates. 

“This is an extraordinary amount of money being stolen and it’s unacceptable,” he said. “Being unaware is not an excuse. The onus is on employers to understand their obligations to their employees,” he said. 

In December, National Tertiary Education Union president Alison Barnes called out universities’ governance models after the union’s analysis found “rampant” wage theft among virtually every major university across the country. 

The NTEU believes that 97,000 staff are owed $159 million, a $50 million increase since its report in February. 

“The fact that wage theft is so widespread in Australian universities is a damning indictment of the current governance model,” she said. 

Ms Barnes said wage theft was driven by the sector’s widespread use of casual staff, with two-thirds of all university workers employed “insecurely” through casual or fixed-term arrangements. 

“If universities are to finally become exemplary employers then we need to end the scourge of casualisation using state and federal powers,” she said. 

The union also said it was involved in eight ongoing cases and echoed the McKell Institute’s suspicions that wage theft estimates understated the true extent of the problem. 

Similarly, the Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees Association sued discount supermarket chain Aldi for $150 million in unpaid wages. “Over $100 million has been ripped out of the pockets of workers and their families by this multi-billion-dollar corporation,” said national secretary Gerard Dwyer. 

The Aldi action came after its biggest competitors, Woolworths and Coles, were also accused of serial underpayments in Federal Court – the FWO sued the supermarket giants in June over setting up payment structures to avoid paying workers overtime. 

To close “loopholes” in the system, the government introduced the Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Closing Loopholes No. 2) Bill 2023 in September to criminalise wage theft and reform casual employment, the gig economy and labour hire laws. 

The bill was then split in two in a crossbench deal on the final day of Parliament to pass its less-contentious provisions on labour hire and union delegate rights.

While unions strongly supported the changes, the corporate sector was not so taken, with key business and employer groups coming out with scathing rebukes. 

Council of Small Business Organisations Australia CEO Luke Achterstraat criticised the complexity of the behemoth 800-page omnibus. “The new definition of casuals is three pages long and comprises 15 different tests. You shouldn’t need a PhD in law to know how to hire a casual worker,” he said. 

National employer association Ai Group CEO Innes Willox called the changes “unworkable”. 

“Make no mistake, the bill will hurt industry, undermine productivity and result in fewer job opportunities as well as higher costs that will potentially be passed on to consumers,” he said. 

With the bill’s remaining provisions on casual work still in Parliament, the ATO also released guidance on differentiating between employees and contractors in December.

TR 2023/4 confirmed the ATO would follow the High Court’s approach to determining whether a worker was an employee under the Taxation Administration Act. 

It said it was a question of fact and should be determined by reference to an objective assessment of the relationship, legal rights and obligations between an employer and employee, a departure from the old “multi-factorial” analysis of parties’ conduct when determining worker classification. 

However, instead of providing clarity, some commentators believed the ruling added a further wrinkle to the employment law landscape. 

This is because it went in direct contrast to the approach contained in Closing Loopholes, which proposed to reinstate the old multi-factorial test. 

According to employment lawyer Nicholas Parkinson, that would lead to an “incongruous position” where the Fair Work Act, FWO, courts and tribunals would use one definition of employment, and the ATO in ensuring compliance with tax obligations would use another. 

A senate inquiry into the bill is due to report next month and the government will look to pass the remaining provisions on casual and gig economy worker protections in the coming months. 

In the meantime, the FWO will almost certainly have its work cut out again in 2024 as businesses and authorities attempt to navigate a system in a constant state of flux.

 

 

 

 

 Christine Chen
11 January 2024
accountantsdaily.com.au

Hot Issues

Disclaimer

The contents hereinafter presented and made accessible on this website are exclusively provided by Advanced Partners, representing general informational materials. The purpose of these materials is solely to serve as guidance and in no case should they be interpreted as counsel or advice on any specific matter.

In using the information provided, you are encouraged to assess its relevance to your individual goals, financial circumstances, and needs. In the event of detailed descriptions of any products being available on this website, you are advised to procure the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) corresponding to said products, and to deliberate on its contents prior to any decision-making.

Advanced Partners extends no assurances or warranties pertaining to uninterrupted, delay-free, error-free, or omission-free operation of the Site, nor its immunity from viruses. Thus, the information is furnished “as is”, bereft of warranties of any kind, express or implied, inclusive of those concerning accuracy, promptness, and completeness.

Advanced Partners and its respective affiliates (be they direct or indirect) renounce all guarantees, obligations, and warranties, be they express or implied, and shall not bear liability for any loss or damage whatsoever (including those resulting from human or computer errors, whether negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential losses or damages) that arise from or are connected with any utilization of or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must undertake sole responsibility related to the use of the material on this site, regardless of the purpose or the outcomes of such usage. The information available on this website should not be considered a replacement for professional tax advice or consultation.

Our liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Privacy Policy

Welcome to Advanced Partners (“we,” “our,” or “us”). This Privacy Policy outlines how we collect, use, disclose, and protect the personal information of our users and customers in Australia. We are committed to safeguarding your privacy and ensuring the security of the information you provide to us. By accessing or using our website, you agree to the practices described in this Privacy Policy.

Information We Collect

We may collect the following types of personal information:

1.1. Personal Identifiers: Name, email address, postal address, phone number, date of birth, and other contact details.

1.2. Account Information: Usernames, passwords, and other credentials used to access our website and services.

1.3. Payment Information: Credit card details or other payment information when making purchases on our website.

1.4. Usage Information: Data about how you interact with our website, such as IP address, browser type, pages viewed, and referring URL.

1.5. Communications: Records of your interactions with us, such as customer support inquiries, feedback, or chat logs.

1.6. Cookies and Similar Technologies: We may use cookies and similar technologies to collect information about your browsing activities on our website.

How We Use Your Information

We use your personal information for the following purposes:

2.1. Service Delivery: To provide you with access to our website and deliver the services you request.

2.2. Communication: To send you important updates, newsletters, and promotional materials (if you’ve opted in) related to our website and services.

2.3. Personalization: To tailor our website content and offerings to your preferences and interests.

2.4. Payment Processing: To process payments for products and services you purchase from us.

2.5. Legal Compliance: To comply with applicable laws, regulations, and legal processes.

How We Share Your Information

We may share your personal information with third parties in the following circumstances:

3.1. Service Providers: We may engage trusted service providers to assist us in operating our website and providing services to you, and they may have access to your personal information for that purpose.

3.2. Legal Obligations: We may disclose your information to comply with legal obligations, enforce our Terms of Service, or protect our rights, privacy, safety, or property.

3.3. Business Transfers: In the event of a merger, acquisition, or sale of all or a portion of our assets, your personal information may be transferred to the acquiring entity.

3.4. Consent: We may share your information with your consent or as otherwise disclosed at the time of collection.

Your Privacy Rights

4.1. Access and Correction: You have the right to access and correct your personal information held by us.

4.2. Marketing Preferences: You can opt-out of receiving marketing communications from us at any time.

4.3. Cookies: You can manage your cookie preferences through your browser settings.

Security

We take reasonable measures to protect your personal information from unauthorized access, disclosure, alteration, or destruction. However, no method of transmission over the internet or electronic storage is entirely secure, and we cannot guarantee absolute security.

Changes to this Privacy Policy

We may update this Privacy Policy from time to time. The most recent version will be posted on our website with the updated effective date.

Contact Us

If you have any questions or concerns about this Privacy Policy or our privacy practices, please contact us.

By using our website, you agree to the terms outlined in this Privacy Policy. If you do not agree with any part of this policy, please refrain from using our website.

Disclaimer

The contents hereinafter presented and made accessible on this website are exclusively provided by Advanced Partners, representing general informational materials. The purpose of these materials is solely to serve as guidance and in no case should they be interpreted as counsel or advice on any specific matter.

In using the information provided, you are encouraged to assess its relevance to your individual goals, financial circumstances, and needs. In the event of detailed descriptions of any products being available on this website, you are advised to procure the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) corresponding to said products, and to deliberate on its contents prior to any decision-making.

Advanced Partners extends no assurances or warranties pertaining to uninterrupted, delay-free, error-free, or omission-free operation of the Site, nor its immunity from viruses. Thus, the information is furnished “as is”, bereft of warranties of any kind, express or implied, inclusive of those concerning accuracy, promptness, and completeness.

Advanced Partners and its respective affiliates (be they direct or indirect) renounce all guarantees, obligations, and warranties, be they express or implied, and shall not bear liability for any loss or damage whatsoever (including those resulting from human or computer errors, whether negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential losses or damages) that arise from or are connected with any utilization of or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must undertake sole responsibility related to the use of the material on this site, regardless of the purpose or the outcomes of such usage. The information available on this website should not be considered a replacement for professional tax advice or consultation.

Our liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.