Logo

How Do I Respond to an Allegation of Trade Mark Infringement?

Imagine you think up a fantastic name for your business and are ready to start operating. You have set up your website and begin advertising online using the business name and logo you have designed.

.

Everything is going great until you receive a letter claiming you have infringed on someone else’s trade mark. This article explores how you can respond to an allegation of trade mark infringement and the available defences.

Understanding the Allegation

If another business (or their lawyers) notifies you that your business’ name or logo infringes on their trade mark rights, it is essential to first assess whether the allegations are true. Once you understand what the registered trade mark owner is claiming, you can respond with a suitable reply that considers the defences available to you.

The Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (TCA) sets out that if a name or logo is substantially identical or deceptively similar to an existing trade mark (and in relation to the same goods or services), it will amount to trade mark infringement. This is the case if the goods or services are the same or closely related.

You may also be infringing someone’s trade mark if it is well-known in Australia, even though it is registered for unrelated goods or services. Given the trade mark’s notoriety, an ordinary person could make a connection between the unrelated goods or services and the registered mark. 

An Example: Using a Well-Known Trade Mark

DC Comics v Cheqout Pty Ltd (2013) 212 FCR 194 (FCA) explains how using a well-known trade mark in bad faith will lead to infringement.  

Cheqout applied to register the name ‘superman workout’ in class 41 for exercise classes. DC Comics opposed the application because it has registered the name ‘Superman’ for various goods and services in Australia. They argued that ‘Superman’ is well-known in Australia. Consequently, it would confuse or deceive the public into thinking the ‘superman workouts’ were associated with the comic book character, ‘Superman’.

The Court stated that ‘Superman’ is undoubtedly a recognisable character. However, without a reference to the indicia of the character, there would be no confusion with the phrase ‘superman workouts’.

Cheqout had maintained that they were not associating the ‘superman workout’ with the ‘Superman’ character. However, evidence showed that Cheqout was using the ‘superman workouts’ phrase together with a shield device recognised as a ‘Superman’ symbol to relate to strength and fitness. As such, the indicia of DC Comics was used in association with the name, meaning Cheqout was using their trade mark in bad faith.

Recent Changes to the Law

It is important to remember that when determining whether two competing trade marks are deceptively similar, the Courts will no longer consider reputation or notoriety in an earlier mark to be a relevant consideration.

This new feature of trade mark infringement in Australia was established in early 2023 through the High Court decision of Self Care IP Holdings Pty Ltd v Allergan Australia Pty Ltd [2023] HCA 8. This case sets a new precedent establishing trade mark infringement in the marketplace. 

Defences to Allegations of Trade Mark Infringement

There are several defences available under the TCA, including using any of the following:

  • a person’s name in good faith (such as part of the name of a company);
  • the name of a person’s place of business in good faith;
  • the name in good faith to describe goods and services; or
  • a name for the purpose of comparative advertising.

If your defence is successful, you can continue using a certain name or logo, and it would not amount to trade mark infringement. 

An Example: Using Your Own Name

Optical 88 Limited v Optical 88 Pty Limited [2011] FCAFC 130 illustrates that you would not be infringing an already registered trade mark where the name you are using is your given name.

Optical 88 Limited is a company incorporated in Hong Kong (Optical 88 HK) with trade marks registered in Australia. It brought an action against Optical 88 Pty Ltd (Optical 88 AUS) for trade mark infringement.

Optical 88 AUS was able to rely on the defence that its use of the words ‘Optical 88’ to run its business was in good faith because it was using its own name.

Additionally, the Court clarified that acting in good faith involves considering whether:

  • it was an honest use of the trade mark;
  • there was intent to deceive the public into an association that doesn’t exist; and
  • the trade mark was trying to appropriate the goodwill that the other business had acquired.

If you believe your use of the registered trade mark was in good faith, you may have a valid defence to using the mark. It is important to speak to a trade mark lawyer to ensure that you respond with every possible available defence to you.

Commercial Considerations

When facing an allegation of trade mark infringement, you should consider whether engaging in a trade marks dispute to defend your position is worthwhile for your business. For instance, your business might be relatively new and are yet to acquire any goodwill or reputation with the public or in your industry. In that case, it may be worthwhile to change your business name or logo to one that is not infringing on someone else’s. This option would certainly be cheaper and less stressful than undergoing potential litigation. 

On the other hand, you may have grown attached to your business name or logo. Likewise, you may have spent considerable sums of money growing your business around your brand and developed a strong presence in your sector under that name. Accordingly, pursuing your case and trying to get a favourable outcome may be commercially sensible to protect your business and trade mark. 

Whether you are fighting your dispute in court or out, it is an expensive and personally taxing process that may still not provide you with a desirable outcome. You should weigh these commercial considerations before responding to an allegation of trade mark infringement.

Key Takeaways

Devising your business’ name and logo is a big part of starting a business. However, you may find yourself at the receiving end of a trade mark infringement notice. The first step is to understand the allegation and consider whether defences are available. It is best practice to speak to a qualified lawyer who can guide you through your options. 

 

 

 

 

Shannon Macdonald
September 8
legalvision.com.au

Hot Issues

Disclaimer

The contents hereinafter presented and made accessible on this website are exclusively provided by Advanced Partners, representing general informational materials. The purpose of these materials is solely to serve as guidance and in no case should they be interpreted as counsel or advice on any specific matter.

In using the information provided, you are encouraged to assess its relevance to your individual goals, financial circumstances, and needs. In the event of detailed descriptions of any products being available on this website, you are advised to procure the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) corresponding to said products, and to deliberate on its contents prior to any decision-making.

Advanced Partners extends no assurances or warranties pertaining to uninterrupted, delay-free, error-free, or omission-free operation of the Site, nor its immunity from viruses. Thus, the information is furnished “as is”, bereft of warranties of any kind, express or implied, inclusive of those concerning accuracy, promptness, and completeness.

Advanced Partners and its respective affiliates (be they direct or indirect) renounce all guarantees, obligations, and warranties, be they express or implied, and shall not bear liability for any loss or damage whatsoever (including those resulting from human or computer errors, whether negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential losses or damages) that arise from or are connected with any utilization of or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must undertake sole responsibility related to the use of the material on this site, regardless of the purpose or the outcomes of such usage. The information available on this website should not be considered a replacement for professional tax advice or consultation.

Our liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Privacy Policy

Welcome to Advanced Partners (“we,” “our,” or “us”). This Privacy Policy outlines how we collect, use, disclose, and protect the personal information of our users and customers in Australia. We are committed to safeguarding your privacy and ensuring the security of the information you provide to us. By accessing or using our website, you agree to the practices described in this Privacy Policy.

Information We Collect

We may collect the following types of personal information:

1.1. Personal Identifiers: Name, email address, postal address, phone number, date of birth, and other contact details.

1.2. Account Information: Usernames, passwords, and other credentials used to access our website and services.

1.3. Payment Information: Credit card details or other payment information when making purchases on our website.

1.4. Usage Information: Data about how you interact with our website, such as IP address, browser type, pages viewed, and referring URL.

1.5. Communications: Records of your interactions with us, such as customer support inquiries, feedback, or chat logs.

1.6. Cookies and Similar Technologies: We may use cookies and similar technologies to collect information about your browsing activities on our website.

How We Use Your Information

We use your personal information for the following purposes:

2.1. Service Delivery: To provide you with access to our website and deliver the services you request.

2.2. Communication: To send you important updates, newsletters, and promotional materials (if you’ve opted in) related to our website and services.

2.3. Personalization: To tailor our website content and offerings to your preferences and interests.

2.4. Payment Processing: To process payments for products and services you purchase from us.

2.5. Legal Compliance: To comply with applicable laws, regulations, and legal processes.

How We Share Your Information

We may share your personal information with third parties in the following circumstances:

3.1. Service Providers: We may engage trusted service providers to assist us in operating our website and providing services to you, and they may have access to your personal information for that purpose.

3.2. Legal Obligations: We may disclose your information to comply with legal obligations, enforce our Terms of Service, or protect our rights, privacy, safety, or property.

3.3. Business Transfers: In the event of a merger, acquisition, or sale of all or a portion of our assets, your personal information may be transferred to the acquiring entity.

3.4. Consent: We may share your information with your consent or as otherwise disclosed at the time of collection.

Your Privacy Rights

4.1. Access and Correction: You have the right to access and correct your personal information held by us.

4.2. Marketing Preferences: You can opt-out of receiving marketing communications from us at any time.

4.3. Cookies: You can manage your cookie preferences through your browser settings.

Security

We take reasonable measures to protect your personal information from unauthorized access, disclosure, alteration, or destruction. However, no method of transmission over the internet or electronic storage is entirely secure, and we cannot guarantee absolute security.

Changes to this Privacy Policy

We may update this Privacy Policy from time to time. The most recent version will be posted on our website with the updated effective date.

Contact Us

If you have any questions or concerns about this Privacy Policy or our privacy practices, please contact us.

By using our website, you agree to the terms outlined in this Privacy Policy. If you do not agree with any part of this policy, please refrain from using our website.

Disclaimer

The contents hereinafter presented and made accessible on this website are exclusively provided by Advanced Partners, representing general informational materials. The purpose of these materials is solely to serve as guidance and in no case should they be interpreted as counsel or advice on any specific matter.

In using the information provided, you are encouraged to assess its relevance to your individual goals, financial circumstances, and needs. In the event of detailed descriptions of any products being available on this website, you are advised to procure the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) corresponding to said products, and to deliberate on its contents prior to any decision-making.

Advanced Partners extends no assurances or warranties pertaining to uninterrupted, delay-free, error-free, or omission-free operation of the Site, nor its immunity from viruses. Thus, the information is furnished “as is”, bereft of warranties of any kind, express or implied, inclusive of those concerning accuracy, promptness, and completeness.

Advanced Partners and its respective affiliates (be they direct or indirect) renounce all guarantees, obligations, and warranties, be they express or implied, and shall not bear liability for any loss or damage whatsoever (including those resulting from human or computer errors, whether negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential losses or damages) that arise from or are connected with any utilization of or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must undertake sole responsibility related to the use of the material on this site, regardless of the purpose or the outcomes of such usage. The information available on this website should not be considered a replacement for professional tax advice or consultation.

Our liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.