Logo

Why employee v contractor comes down to fine print

The task of worker classification has been a long-running point of contention but the Commissioner’s response to recent court cases suggests a written contract is king.

.

The classification of an individual as an employee or contractor for PAYG and superannuation obligations has been a long-running point of contention.

With the High Court decisions of Jamsek and Personnel Contracting changing the determination process, together with the recent case of JMC Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation potentially expanding the role of the contractor, the question before us now is: where are we with the Commissioner’s response?

Background

In 2022, Jamsek and Personal Contracting determined that the terms and conditions of a written contract between parties were what was relevant when deciding whether an individual providing services is characterised as an employee or a contractor. 

 

As a result, a written agreement between parties contains the determining factors in the employee v contractor issue (control, risk, integration of the individual into the principal’s business).

Provided the agreement is not a sham or has not been varied, it is not necessary for further facts and/or evidence to be gathered or considered by the parties in determining the outcome.

JMC Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2023]

JMC was a superannuation case concerning whether sections 12(1) and 12(3) of the Superannuation Guarantee Administration Act 1992 applied to a contract primarily for labour.

The decision is important because including a term that allows for delegating or transferring someone's services in the written agreement will likely lead to them being characterised as a contractor instead of an employee.

The Full Federal Court clearly stated (paragraph 89):

“The right bestowed upon Mr Harrison to subcontract or assign the performance of his teaching services, subject to written consent, was a real and substantial right which was inconsistent with an employment relationship between him and JMC.”

This decision expands the potential for individuals to be engaged as contractors where their agreements have such a delegation authority, regardless of whether the principal approves the delegation. The fact that it exists is the primary issue.

This means that a principal may directly hire an individual for services without the need for any intermediary entity.

The Commissioner’s position

Taxation ruling TR 2023/4 outlines the Commissioner’s position.

It starts in a somewhat pedestrian fashion on the question “who is an employee” for PAYG, and reemphasises that it will be approached in a “holistic” manner.

But the key points in the ruling with respect to the question of employee v contractor are as follows:

  1. The delegation authority

The Commissioner accepts the position that a right to delegate or assign services, as evidenced in a written agreement, will indicate that the individual is not an employee.

However, there will be parameters in the contractual terms:

  •       Not be limited in scope (that is, the worker can delegate, subcontract, or assign the entirety of their work to another, as opposed to only discrete tasks)
  •       Not be a sham, and
  •       Be legally capable of being exercised.

The Commissioner goes on to state: “Whether the worker is, however, an independent contractor will depend upon an examination of the totality of the legal rights and obligations between the parties.”

It is unclear what the Commissioner means by this. It would appear without doubt that in JMC the weighting to the question of delegation was the substantial factor in favour of characterising an individual as a contractor (independent or otherwise).

  1. The comprehensive written agreement

A comprehensive written agreement that governs the entire relationship between the parties will be the evidentiary document in considering the employee and contractor divide. 

The Commissioner states:

“Where the worker and the engaging entity have comprehensively committed the terms of their relationship to a written contract and the validity of that contract has not been challenged as a sham, nor have the terms of the contract otherwise been varied, waived, discharged or the subject of an estoppel or any equitable, legal or statutory right or remedy, it is the legal rights and obligations in the contract alone that are relevant in determining whether the worker is an employee of an engaging entity.”

Notably, the Commissioner accepts that “evidence of how the contract was performed, including subsequent conduct and work practices, cannot be considered for determining the nature of the legal relationship between the parties”.

Consistent with this, the respective practical compliance guideline (PCG 2023/2) says that there will be low or very low risk outcomes where parties have a written contract expressing the employee v contractor outcome.

  1. The requirement for written advice

PCG 2023/2 also indicates that each party must commit to and understand the worker classification in their agreement.

The party relying on this classification will fall within the ‘”no risk” or “very low risk” category if they have “obtained specific advice confirming the classification was correct”.

The specific advice does not need to be in writing, but if it is, that will be given greater weighting in the Commissioner’s determination.

Takeaways

The employee v contractor classification is not straightforward.

The High Court’s direction has limited the question to the written agreement (where one is in place). However, issues and disputes between parties regularly arise for “handshake” agreements between friends when the relationship subsequently sours.

The lesson in such matters is simply to get everything in writing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Phillip London
16 February 2024
accountantsdaily.com.au

 

Hot Issues

Disclaimer

The contents hereinafter presented and made accessible on this website are exclusively provided by Advanced Partners, representing general informational materials. The purpose of these materials is solely to serve as guidance and in no case should they be interpreted as counsel or advice on any specific matter.

In using the information provided, you are encouraged to assess its relevance to your individual goals, financial circumstances, and needs. In the event of detailed descriptions of any products being available on this website, you are advised to procure the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) corresponding to said products, and to deliberate on its contents prior to any decision-making.

Advanced Partners extends no assurances or warranties pertaining to uninterrupted, delay-free, error-free, or omission-free operation of the Site, nor its immunity from viruses. Thus, the information is furnished “as is”, bereft of warranties of any kind, express or implied, inclusive of those concerning accuracy, promptness, and completeness.

Advanced Partners and its respective affiliates (be they direct or indirect) renounce all guarantees, obligations, and warranties, be they express or implied, and shall not bear liability for any loss or damage whatsoever (including those resulting from human or computer errors, whether negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential losses or damages) that arise from or are connected with any utilization of or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must undertake sole responsibility related to the use of the material on this site, regardless of the purpose or the outcomes of such usage. The information available on this website should not be considered a replacement for professional tax advice or consultation.

Our liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Privacy Policy

Welcome to Advanced Partners (“we,” “our,” or “us”). This Privacy Policy outlines how we collect, use, disclose, and protect the personal information of our users and customers in Australia. We are committed to safeguarding your privacy and ensuring the security of the information you provide to us. By accessing or using our website, you agree to the practices described in this Privacy Policy.

Information We Collect

We may collect the following types of personal information:

1.1. Personal Identifiers: Name, email address, postal address, phone number, date of birth, and other contact details.

1.2. Account Information: Usernames, passwords, and other credentials used to access our website and services.

1.3. Payment Information: Credit card details or other payment information when making purchases on our website.

1.4. Usage Information: Data about how you interact with our website, such as IP address, browser type, pages viewed, and referring URL.

1.5. Communications: Records of your interactions with us, such as customer support inquiries, feedback, or chat logs.

1.6. Cookies and Similar Technologies: We may use cookies and similar technologies to collect information about your browsing activities on our website.

How We Use Your Information

We use your personal information for the following purposes:

2.1. Service Delivery: To provide you with access to our website and deliver the services you request.

2.2. Communication: To send you important updates, newsletters, and promotional materials (if you’ve opted in) related to our website and services.

2.3. Personalization: To tailor our website content and offerings to your preferences and interests.

2.4. Payment Processing: To process payments for products and services you purchase from us.

2.5. Legal Compliance: To comply with applicable laws, regulations, and legal processes.

How We Share Your Information

We may share your personal information with third parties in the following circumstances:

3.1. Service Providers: We may engage trusted service providers to assist us in operating our website and providing services to you, and they may have access to your personal information for that purpose.

3.2. Legal Obligations: We may disclose your information to comply with legal obligations, enforce our Terms of Service, or protect our rights, privacy, safety, or property.

3.3. Business Transfers: In the event of a merger, acquisition, or sale of all or a portion of our assets, your personal information may be transferred to the acquiring entity.

3.4. Consent: We may share your information with your consent or as otherwise disclosed at the time of collection.

Your Privacy Rights

4.1. Access and Correction: You have the right to access and correct your personal information held by us.

4.2. Marketing Preferences: You can opt-out of receiving marketing communications from us at any time.

4.3. Cookies: You can manage your cookie preferences through your browser settings.

Security

We take reasonable measures to protect your personal information from unauthorized access, disclosure, alteration, or destruction. However, no method of transmission over the internet or electronic storage is entirely secure, and we cannot guarantee absolute security.

Changes to this Privacy Policy

We may update this Privacy Policy from time to time. The most recent version will be posted on our website with the updated effective date.

Contact Us

If you have any questions or concerns about this Privacy Policy or our privacy practices, please contact us.

By using our website, you agree to the terms outlined in this Privacy Policy. If you do not agree with any part of this policy, please refrain from using our website.

Disclaimer

The contents hereinafter presented and made accessible on this website are exclusively provided by Advanced Partners, representing general informational materials. The purpose of these materials is solely to serve as guidance and in no case should they be interpreted as counsel or advice on any specific matter.

In using the information provided, you are encouraged to assess its relevance to your individual goals, financial circumstances, and needs. In the event of detailed descriptions of any products being available on this website, you are advised to procure the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) corresponding to said products, and to deliberate on its contents prior to any decision-making.

Advanced Partners extends no assurances or warranties pertaining to uninterrupted, delay-free, error-free, or omission-free operation of the Site, nor its immunity from viruses. Thus, the information is furnished “as is”, bereft of warranties of any kind, express or implied, inclusive of those concerning accuracy, promptness, and completeness.

Advanced Partners and its respective affiliates (be they direct or indirect) renounce all guarantees, obligations, and warranties, be they express or implied, and shall not bear liability for any loss or damage whatsoever (including those resulting from human or computer errors, whether negligent or otherwise, or incidental or consequential losses or damages) that arise from or are connected with any utilization of or reliance on the information or advice on this site. The user must undertake sole responsibility related to the use of the material on this site, regardless of the purpose or the outcomes of such usage. The information available on this website should not be considered a replacement for professional tax advice or consultation.

Our liability is limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.